I just saw some highlights, but it jsut looked like a the tape was a loop of Yousuf helping himself to endless desserts - wide long-hops and juicy half-volleys. The attack is pretty thin right now, so this was bound to happen at some point, but the nature in which the wheels fell off the juggernaut-wannabe was kind of surprising. What was different about the Ashes attack (apart from the faces) was the relentlessness - you had to hit the good balls for 4 if you wanted runs, now it’s just a case of help yourself. Even in India, the bowling was pretty tight and probing; hardly the case here. Looks like the exaggereated praise has got to the bowlers esp. Harmison and Mahmood. And you can’t be here today gone tomorrow like Harmison is right now.
What went wrong for England?
By Will 2 years ago, mid-August Leave a comment on this post
Perhaps I’m jaded and cynical but watching England today conjured memories of a bygone era. A near-silent crowd; glum expressions from the fielders; bowling of such inadequacy that it makes you cringe. This was the bad old England and it was bad old viewing.
In blaming England’s performance I am not doing Pakistan a disservice. They batted magnificently well given the circumstances, that much cannot be denied. But they were allowed to. Never were their stumps threatened, were they put under pressure or ever gave the impression of batting in a Test match. It was the most forgettable bowling display, led - or rather not - by Steve Harmison.
A colleague once called him the new Andrew Caddick, a notion which six months ago I scoffed at. If I’m honest, I agreed with him but was reticent to truly believe it. Now, though, the evidence is too damning to ignore. 2004, his rise to the top of the world rankings, was his career highlight. It is very unlikely he will ever reach such a peak again. What astonishes me, and no doubt you too, is the cavernous gap in quality or effectiveness he can show between one Test and the next; will he be Jekyll or Hyde? Indeed, hiding is something he would dearly have loved to do today. Like Harmison, Caddick could be utterly devastating one minute and a club-trundler the next. The difference in performance - be it per session, month, Test or whatever - is so stark as to be incomprehensible. How can someone so naturally talented, so rich in assets be so utterly ineffective so regularly?
What went wrong, then, for England? Complacency? Ashes fever? Not only was the bowling embarrassingly short and wide, but the fielding no better than slapdash. I’m away for a few days and quite honestly I’m quite glad not to be watching every ball of the remaining three days. Your thoughts on today’s performance, if you have any, can be posted below.
Tags: england, pakistan, pakistan-in-england, steve-harmison |
18 Responses to “What went wrong for England?”
August 19th, 2006 at 2.14 am
August 19th, 2006 at 3.00 am
From the way you describe it Will it sounds like the Poms are preparing for their usual lambasting by the Aussies.
August 19th, 2006 at 3.38 am
I’m a pak fan. I have noticed that England really do go over the top when they win and hit absolute rock bottom when they start to lose. Who doesn’t know by now that you can’t ask Harmison to deliver in every match. He has only one weapon which is uncomfortable bounce. This can be effective in every match BUT he has little to no control over where the ball will end up. When the pitch is extra bouncy just getting a few deliveries in the right areas will get him wickets. On the other hand when the pitch is not helpful, the few deliveries he gets in the business area can be fended off. He is much like shoaib akhtar. I don’t expect him to come off with a great performance in every match. He has deadly 95mph+ pace but if it isn’t well directed, it just makes the ball get to the boundary faster.
The return of Asif has really cheered me up. Finally, Pak has a bowler that can get 4 out of 6 balls in the corridor. He just gets a little nip in and out. The pressure this creates is much more effective than akhtar’s scatter gun. Being a Pak fan I know that Pak can come back from a hopeless situation and also collapse in a heap from almost certain victory. Therefore, I will reserve my judgement on pak’s prospects till the end of day 3. The best way to watch pak is to expect the worst and then be pleasantly surprised if they do well. Otherwise, I would lose all my hair at the age of 25 something I’m trying to avoid till my late 40s.
August 19th, 2006 at 3.49 am
I see history repeated. You never know what you will get from England. Full credit to Pakistan for playing a fine game and taking each bloody rotten ball as it comes. I expect no less of them. But I did expect more of England.
Time and again, no decent line or length. Did the bowling threaten Pakistan. Did it buggery. I have seen more aggression in a kitten. Even dumb-nut me could face that bowling and score a few - perhaps (ah gosh!) more than Trescothick, which is not superhuman at this moment in time.
Dead-rubber mentality? England, get out of it, quick! The Aussies will not be so forgiving.
August 19th, 2006 at 5.18 am
England must be missing the guidance of Troy Cooley; Unchecked Harmison’s inconsistency really drags the team down, he is an immature cricketer, i have played lots of cricket and there is nothing more frustrating than a manchild quick bowler.
That said i still think they can win this test, they are becoming quite an enigmatic team.
August 19th, 2006 at 7.50 am
If England take this form to Australia, Australia will feast & win 5-0.
August 19th, 2006 at 10.12 am
Last week they were gods, and now they’re crap. C’est la vie. Maybe some of those old injured players were important after all. Gilo would have taken that catch…;-)
August 19th, 2006 at 10.16 am
Hi Japaddy, got one of those manchild-bowler types in my team at the moment. He scored 102 on debut, took 7 for 21 last season and has been fit for nothing this season. Sigh.
August 19th, 2006 at 10.40 am
Not quite left for hols yet (supposed to be packing
Anyway, I’ve heard rumours about Kevin Shine not being well liked at Somerset because he was (allegedly) quite overbearing. Troy Cooley would sit back and make fine adjustments to each bowler, just giving them 1 or 2 simple things to work on at a time. Rajeev reminded me that the bowling was pretty tight in India - what’s the major factor since then? I think it’s got to be the change of bowling coach. Interesting that Will mentions Harmison as the new Andrew Caddick - I really hope that doesn’t happen, but I can see the potential.
On the other hand, we’re all fretting more than usual because the Ashes are coming up, and the thought of handing them back without a fight is just a bit too much to bear - especially as I’m planning on being there!
August 19th, 2006 at 2.18 pm
Hoggard and Harmison struggled, Mahmood is as Mahmood does and Monty wasn’t getting much from the pitch.
It’s not the end of the world, everyone knows Harmison will never be the consistent world beater we thought he could be after the Windies tour. And Hoggard did bowl some good stuff, we just couldn’t catch the ones he got right.
This is what happens when we only have 2 pace bowlers who are capable of delivering, it all goes to pot when they don’t. In the ashes last year, we had 4 quality quick bowlers, Harmison and Hoggard were pretty crap last season aswell but no one noticed because we had Freddie and Jones to take up the slack. This kind of performance was bound to happen one day when we spend the whole summer with Only 2 quality quick bowlers.
I honestly don’t know why we keep picking Mahmood.
August 19th, 2006 at 2.34 pm
I count myself as being among Steve Harmison’s biggest supporters, but even I am lost for words over this recent display. I hate reading critical comments about him, because I know they can only serve to knock the confidence even more, and I’m really hoping that he can get a breakthrough before long, just to up his confidence. I don’t think there’s anything more disheartening than the sight of Harmy, trudging back to his mark after sending down another wide, shaking his head and frowning, especially when Hoggy’s off-colour too. This may anger a lot of people here, but I might switch over to the football in minute…
August 19th, 2006 at 2.54 pm
I take it back, he just sent down a wicket maiden, is he back?? Lets chuffin’ well hope so.
P.S I didn’t really mean it about the football, honest.
August 19th, 2006 at 3.44 pm
Come on folks - relax, and stop overreating.
It’s a bad couple of days at the office- bit too early to start writing off our chances this winter. based on that.
As I write this, Pakistan are now 398-6, unlikely to get more than 500, and who’s going to bet that we don’t knuckle down and make a similar score next time up?
You can be sure that Fletcher will have read the riot act to quite a few of the batsmen and reminded them that they’re not on the plane to Australia quite yet.
What are the odds on us winning this one - might be worth a bob or two….
August 19th, 2006 at 3.54 pm
How did you know i was overeating?
Charlie Bucket your comments made me go all teary,of course your right Harmy is a gentle soul, and as he is a manchild we should take more care to nurture, i too want only the best for the young man.
August 19th, 2006 at 4.35 pm
Christ, I’m such a girl!!! (I am actually a girl, so I guess that’s allowed). Japaddy, it’s nice to know that there’s a kindred soul out there. I know he probably needs a bit of a kick up the arse once in a while, but I don’t see how the media can hope to encourage people by suggesting they’re not fit for the bloody team. Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr. It really cheeses me off.
And I lied again about the football, hopefully when Harmy hears Newcastle are winning, he might get even more impetus!!!!!
August 19th, 2006 at 5.35 pm
Okay, so now there’s REALLY no need to criticise, not when Trescothick can take catches like that laying down. Surely we’ve just been toying with Pakistan all this time, and now good old Harmy the manchild has cleaned up the tail, Straussy and Trezza are gonna bat Pakistan out of the game. Betcha.
I hope.
August 19th, 2006 at 8.44 pm
totally complacent until today - that was the issue. the aussies used to do it to us - thrashed us and gave up the ghost in the last test.
i think well come together in australia. if we get freddie back and firing i think well be ok. although i do worry about the fourth seamer. apparently anderson is strting bowling again soon - could be good news for england. mahmood has a lot of improving to do still. i think we will miss jones a lot in Oz, so hopefully anderson can come back to the form he was in before he got injured.
August 19th, 2006 at 9.31 pm
Is it possible that Harmy misses Fred out there? Not just as a fellow fast bowler but as his pal, to help gee him up?
Comments
« Live chat: Eng v Pak, 4th Test, The Oval, 2nd day | Main | Live chat: Eng v Pak, 4th Test, The Oval, 3rd day »
